2021 US Claim Satisfaction Up From Soaring Vehicle Values And Straight-Through-Processing

J.D. Power says the surge in used vehicle prices across the US has given an unexpected boost to vehicle insurance customers who experience a total loss, with their vehicles possibly worth more than owners thought.

According to the J.D. Power 2021 US Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, the phenomenon of higher replacement values, combined with advancements in straight-through-processing (STP), has driven customer satisfaction with auto insurance claims to a record high.

However, despite the gains, the industry is facing new challenges of increased vehicle complexity thanks to the growth of advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), which are contributing to rising severity cost.

“The auto insurance industry has been investing heavily in streamlining the claims process and those investments are starting to pay off in the form of faster cycle times and record levels of satisfaction,” said Tom Super, Head of Property and Casualty Insurance Intelligence at J.D. Power. “The challenge now will be continuing to drive service improvements as vehicle prices normalise and claim severity continues to increase. Those carriers with more sophisticated claimant triage will be better positioned to navigate the growing cost and complexity ahead.”

Redesigned for 2021, the US Auto Claims Satisfaction Study is based on responses from 7345 vehicle insurance customers who settled a claim within the past six months prior to taking the survey. The study excludes claimants whose vehicle incurred only glass or windshield damage, was stolen, or who only filed a roadside assistance claim. The study was fielded from November 2020 to September 2021.


  • Record-high customer satisfaction: Overall satisfaction with the vehicle insurance claims process increased to a record-high 880 (on a 1000-point scale), up eight points from 2020. This is the fourth consecutive year of improvement in vehicle claims satisfaction, which has been driven by year-over-year increases in performance across five of six factors measured in the study: first notice of loss, claim servicing, estimation process, repair process, and settlement. Growth in settlement, first notice of loss and estimation process factors were the primary drivers of the overall increase in satisfaction.
  • STP investments paying off: Claims that can be processed via a low-touch experience, in which the entire process from first notice of loss to a direct repair shop resulted in the highest levels of satisfaction (915) in the study. In contrast, claimants who had to interact more manually and with three or more representatives during the claims process had the lowest levels of customer satisfaction.
  • ADAS features add complexity, cost: Among claimants with low- to mid-severity claims, 66 per cent indicated that their vehicle was equipped with ADAS features. Claims associated with ADAS-equipped vehicles are about 13.5 per cent higher on average than non-ADAS-equipped vehicles.
  • Claimant profile predictive of claims outcomes: Claimants whose at-fault status is in dispute have the lowest overall customer satisfaction scores. Claimants who are the most price-sensitive can still experience a positive claims process, in which case their likelihood to renew can be heavily influenced.